https://reurl.cc/6qAO5V
文中排名不是單純看故事性
所以多數人討厭的鼓人
排名應該就比很多人心中的高
其中不管是：
例行賽碾壓程度
季後賽對手強度
陣容強度
季後賽是否一面倒車過去
等各種因素均考慮進去
所以「強度」是主要考量
比賽精彩度還是故事性可能只是次要
文中也有FOX三老及Pierzynski跟火車
去評價那些年的冠軍
只列排名不然文章會過長
對各年排名的理由
有興趣的人再去看看
#25 — St. Louis Cardinals (2006)
Regular Season: 83–78 (1st in NL Central)
NLDS: Defeated Padres, 3–1
NLCS: Defeated Mets, 4–3
World Series: Defeated Tigers, 4–1
#24 — San Francisco Giants (2014)
Regular Season: 88–74 (2nd in NL West)
Wild Card Game: Defeated Pirates
NLDS: Defeated Nationals, 3–1
NLCS: Defeated Cardinals, 4–1
World Series: Defeated Royals, 4–3
#23 — St. Louis Cardinals (2011)
Regular Season: 90–72 (2nd in NL Central)
NLDS: Defeated Phillies, 3–2
NLCS: Defeated Brewers, 4–2
World Series: Defeated Rangers, 4–3
#22 — San Francisco Giants (2012)
Regular Season: 94–68 (1st in NL West)
NLDS: Defeated Reds, 3–2
NLCS: Defeated Cardinals, 4–3
World Series: Defeated Tigers, 4–0
#21 — Florida Marlins (2003)
Regular Season: 91–71 (2nd in NL East)
NLDS: Defeated Giants, 3–1
NLCS: Defeated Cubs, 4–3
World Series: Defeated Yankees, 4–2
#20 — New York Yankees (2000)
Regular Season: 87–74 (1st in AL East)
ALDS: Defeated Athletics, 3–2
ALCS: Defeated Mariners, 4–2
World Series: Defeated Mets, 4–1
#19 — Philadelphia Phillies (2008)
Regular Season: 92–70 (1st in NL East)
NLDS: Defeated Brewers, 3–1
NLCS: Defeated Dodgers, 4–1
World Series: Defeated Rays, 4–1
#18 — San Francisco Giants (2010)
Regular Season: 92–70 (1st in NL West)
NLDS: Defeated Braves, 3–1
NLCS: Defeated Phillies, 4–2
World Series: Defeated Rangers, 4–1
#17 — Kansas City Royals (2015)
Regular Season: 95–67 (1st in AL Central)
ALDS: Defeated Astros, 3–2
ALCS: Defeated Blue Jays, 4–2
World Series: Defeated Mets, 4–1
#16 — Atlanta Braves (2021)
Regular Season: 88–73 (1st in NL East)
NLDS: Defeated Brewers, 3–1
NLCS: Defeated Dodgers, 4–2
World Series: Defeated Astros, 4–2
#15 — Chicago White Sox (2005)
Regular Season: 99–63 (1st in AL Central)
ALDS: Defeated Red Sox, 3–0
ALCS: Defeated Angels, 4–1
World Series: Defeated Astros, 4–0
#14 — Texas Rangers (2023)
Regular Season: 90–72 (2nd in AL West)
Wild Card Series: Defeated Rays, 2–0
ALDS: Defeated Orioles, 3–0
ALCS: Defeated Astros, 4–3
World Series: Defeated Diamondbacks, 4–1
#13 — Arizona Diamondbacks (2001)
Regular Season: 92–70 (1st in NL West)
NLDS: Defeated Cardinals, 3–2
NLCS: Defeated Braves, 4–1
World Series: Defeated Yankees, 4–3
#12 — Los Angeles Dodgers (2024)
Regular Season: 98–64 (1st in NL West)
NLDS: Defeated Padres, 3–2
NLCS: Defeated Mets, 4–2
World Series: Defeated Yankees, 4–1
#11 — 2019 Washington Nationals
Regular Season: 93–69 (2nd in NL East)
Wild Card Game: Defeated Brewers
NLDS: Defeated Dodgers, 3–2
NLCS: Defeated Cardinals, 4–0
World Series: Defeated Astros, 4–3
#10 — Boston Red Sox (2004)
Regular Season: 98–64 (2nd in AL East)
ALDS: Defeated Angels, 3–0
ALCS: Defeated Yankees, 4–3
World Series: Defeated Cardinals, 4–0
#9 — Houston Astros (2017)
Regular Season: 101–61 (1st in AL West)
ALDS: Defeated Red Sox, 3–1
ALCS: Defeated Yankees, 4–3
World Series: Defeated Dodgers, 4–3
#8 — Boston Red Sox (2013)
Regular Season: 97–65 (1st in AL East)
ALDS: Defeated Rays, 3–1
ALCS: Defeated Tigers, 4–2
World Series: Defeated Cardinals, 4–2
#7 — Anaheim Angels (2002)
Regular Season: 99–63 (2nd in AL West)
ALDS: Defeated Yankees, 3–1
ALCS: Defeated Twins, 4–1
World Series: Defeated Giants, 4–3
#6 — 2020 Los Angeles Dodgers
Regular Season: 43–17 (1st in NL West)
Wild Card Series: Defeated Brewers, 2–0
NLDS: Defeated Padres, 3–0
NLCS: Defeated Braves, 4–3
World Series: Defeated Rays, 4–2
#5 — Boston Red Sox (2007)
Regular Season: 96–66 (1st in AL East)
ALDS: Defeated Angels, 3–0
ALCS: Defeated Cleveland, 4–3
World Series: Defeated Rockies, 4–0
#4 — New York Yankees (2009)
Regular Season: 103–59 (1st in AL East)
ALDS: Defeated Twins, 3–0
ALCS: Defeated Angels, 4–2
World Series: Defeated Phillies, 4–2
#3 — 2022 Houston Astros
Regular Season: 106–56 (1st in AL West)
ALDS: Defeated Mariners, 3–0
ALCS: Defeated Yankees, 4–0
World Series: Defeated Phillies, 4–2
#2 — Chicago Cubs (2016)
Regular Season: 103–58-1 (1st in NL Central)
NLDS: Defeated Giants, 3–1
NLCS: Defeated Dodgers, 4–2
World Series: Defeated Cleveland, 4–3
#1 — Boston Red Sox (2018)
Regular Season: 108–54 (1st in AL East)
ALDS: Defeated Yankees, 3–1
ALCS: Defeated Astros, 4–1
World Series: Defeated Dodgers, 4–1
這榜單算合理嗎？
有哪些年是太高或是太低？
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 49.216.185.73 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://webptt.cc/bbs/Baseball/M.1761195637.A.406.html
推文 (38)
推
ct13579
2020道奇照勝場比例放大到162場會拿116勝
10/23 13:06
→
jeff1013
那年縮水賽季 誰來排應該都不太可能排太高
10/23 13:07
→
jeff1013
排到第六我覺得算挺前面的了
10/23 13:08
→
jeff1013
而且季後賽打勇士跟光芒也都不算太碾
10/23 13:08
推
kyc1005
2017太空人應該要排第一吧，有最新科技怎麼輸
10/23 13:13
推
try13286
鼓人粉的榜單
10/23 13:14
推
same60710
要比故事性就沒什麼好比的 前兩名一定2016和2001
10/23 13:14
推
k385476916
13要比18高才對
10/23 13:15
→
jeff1013
你講故事性 01怎可能贏04紅襪
10/23 13:16
→
jeff1013
先0：3逆轉打贏洋基破貝比魯斯魔咒 WS直接橫掃沒讓紅雀
10/23 13:17
→
jeff1013
領先過一局破80多年的無冠魔咒
10/23 13:17
→
jeff1013
13也是故事性比18高吧 但這榜單更偏重整體強度
10/23 13:18
推
k385476916
強度的話 那確實
10/23 13:18
噓
Texsogood
17年咚咚咚排第九XD
10/23 13:25
推
Alcaraz7777
純實力18第一名應該沒毛病
10/23 13:29
推
kaigogo
05白襪應該前面點 整個季後賽只輸1場
10/23 13:31
推
minihyde
2014 G7 瘋邦先發休兩天後援 不給皇家活路
10/23 13:31
→
alex2426chen
13年就老爹一個打全部 G4關鍵精神喊話也很關鍵
10/23 13:32
推
Hsu1025
作弊居然不用除名
10/23 13:40
→
BaRanKa
21年88勝我勇才16名
10/23 13:57
→
BryceChang
2019故事性也可以排前五啦
10/23 13:57
→
jeff1013
應該就是因為例行賽只有88勝所以沒排太高吧
10/23 13:58
推
ct13579
2006紅雀也是例行賽史上勝率最低的世界大賽冠軍吧
10/23 13:59
→
jeff1013
除了縮水賽季的20賽季 勇士已經是低於90勝的冠軍中在這
10/23 13:59
→
jeff1013
榜單排最高的
10/23 13:59
→
BaRanKa
20年我本來也覺得不會輸LAD的Orz
10/23 14:01
→
jeff1013
不知 沒查過相關資料w 不過83勝在非縮水賽季的狀況下
10/23 14:01
→
jeff1013
是真的算挺少的
10/23 14:01
→
BaRanKa
好險21年報仇壓過去
10/23 14:02
→
jeff1013
20年勇士其實還真的差點就贏道奇了
10/23 14:02
→
jeff1013
然後我也覺得白襪那冠似乎被排的有點低
10/23 14:06
推
kenkuo1688
2016故事性屌打 還讓1追3
10/23 14:11
推
spreesell6
18的紅襪真的強，還很強盛的太空人道奇都被輾壓
10/23 15:56
→
jeff1013
文中給18紅襪第一名的理由的確一部分就是季後賽打贏的
10/23 16:28
→
jeff1013
對手
10/23 16:28
→
jeff1013
當年洋基也100勝 太空人103勝 道奇雖然比較少也有92勝
10/23 16:28
→
jeff1013
結果三隊該年季後賽都分別只能贏下一場
10/23 16:29
推
LionKill
18襪不是有作弊爭議嗎
10/24 00:39