Who is in the mix for MLB's top three individual awards — MVP, Cy Young, and Ro
okie of the Year?
FOX Sports' @DeeshaThosar and @RowanKavner gave their picks
foxsports.com/stories/mlb/20…
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/G0lf29caMAIahZn.jpg
https://x.com/MLBONFOX/status/1966208200350511485
FOX兩位專家的預測
只有國聯的新人王有分歧
關於美聯MVP，這兩人的理由
It seems like all we’ve heard around baseball since the second half of the seas
on is the AL MVP debate. Let’s not make this complicated. It comes down to the
numbers. Judge has a 192 wRC+ and 7.9 fWAR; Raleigh has about a 158 wRC+ and 7.3
fWAR. Judge is slashing .321/.442/.660 with 44 homers; Raleigh is at roughly .2
40/.349/.574 with 53 homers. I’m not convinced that everything Raleigh does as
a switch-hitting catcher is enough to bridge the gap in Judge’s rate stats and
on-base/slugging advantage — roughly an 86-point difference in slugging — so t
his one still belongs to Judge. – Deesha Thosar
My heart says Cal Raleigh, but my head says Judge, who holds the advantage over
not only Raleigh but every qualified MLB hitter in every slash line category. Ju
dge shouldn’t be penalized just because this season isn’t quite as ridiculous
as last year, which was one of the greatest seasons from a right-handed hitter e
ver. His OPS is more than 150 points better than the next closest AL competitor,
he has reached base safely in 118 of his 133 games, and he had a terrific defen
sive season before the elbow injury. We shouldn’t lose sight of how ridiculous
he has been. – Rowan Kavner
大意就是覺得法官除了全壘打以外的打擊數據贏Raleigh太多了
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 223.139.21.7 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://webptt.cc/bbs/Baseball/M.1757645289.A.002.html
※ 編輯: polanco (223.139.21.7 臺灣), 09/12/2025 10:49:19
推文 (60)
推
jack8587
Maga之力今天又2轟，羅里要贏大概得拼60轟
09/12 10:49
→
lmf770410
還是法官
09/12 10:50
推
same60710
主要就是很多人只會看到看到Raleigh刷HR 沒注意其實他
09/12 10:50
推
stardream226
MVP大概五年內都是這兩位
09/12 10:50
→
same60710
後半賽季根本打的超爛...
09/12 10:50
推
RodrigueZ810
今天後fwar應該會拉開到0.5以上
09/12 10:51
推
huangjyuan
法官今天衝一波
09/12 10:52
推
edhuang
Horton跟鬼一樣
09/12 10:52
推
qscxz
五年不好說 但明年幾乎也是這兩位
09/12 10:53
推
dd1115dd1115
Cal Raleigh其他數據真的輸太多了
09/12 10:54
推
yankees733
美聯MVP還很難說啦 看誰最後鳥掉誰就輸了
09/12 10:55
→
hy654
投票的不會只看數據就投票 破捕手全壘打紀錄跟守位是捕手一
09/12 10:57
→
hy654
定多少有加成
09/12 10:57
→
hy654
我是覺得 還很難講
09/12 10:57
推
jack8587
國聯真的沒對手，大谷未來有機會打破bb爺7mvp的紀錄
09/12 10:57
推
zego41
雷利之前看起來很穩，如果打擊率再跌下去.23 就涼了
09/12 10:58
推
howard1997
雷利除了全壘打之外真的差太多 難吧
09/12 11:00
推
ohmyya
拉利第二名票應該很多
09/12 11:00
推
MoWilliams
雷利也撞牆撞的很嚴重
09/12 11:01
推
sunwit
今天之前法官WAR也才領先0.4
09/12 11:06
推
RodrigueZ810
可能就像一個多月前PCA的war領先但大家還是認為大
09/12 11:08
→
RodrigueZ810
谷的原因吧
09/12 11:08
推
kayuzzo15135
沒有五年吧 法官都33了五年不就到37
09/12 11:09
推
Yjizz
蘿莉最近稍涼或是被IBB, Last7三圍 .200.375.440
09/12 11:09
→
RodrigueZ810
cal很多是守備位撐高的war所以票選比較不吃香，可
09/12 11:09
→
RodrigueZ810
能跟紀錄加成抵消了
09/12 11:09
→
Diaw0803
法官OPS贏那麼多 全聯盟也只有大谷能看到車尾燈
09/12 11:12
推
kayuzzo15135
哪有只有全壘打 打點也贏法官阿
09/12 11:12
推
huangjyuan
蘿莉參加全壘打大賽應該也是有關係
09/12 11:14
推
phf5566
沒有什麼往後5年都是這兩人 法官已經33了 之後狀態往下掉
09/12 11:18
→
phf5566
都是正常的 大谷也已經30了 再加上雙刀對身體的負擔 期待
09/12 11:18
→
phf5566
兩個人未來再巔峰個5年不切實際
09/12 11:18
→
saidon
五年內沒對手可能性不大拉 尤其法官33了不太可能未來五年
09/12 11:21
→
saidon
還能維持這種狀態
09/12 11:21
推
atmmaxing
雷利什麼時候看起來很穩了XD
09/12 11:27
推
andy0305
水手拚個美西龍頭可能還有機會吧
09/12 11:34
推
kayuzzo15135
雷利要55以上才有一拼的機會吧
09/12 11:34
→
kayuzzo15135
樓上mvp戰績又不是很重要 不然大谷在天使哪能拿
09/12 11:34
→
kayuzzo15135
更何況洋基戰績也不爛
09/12 11:34
推
kirimaru73
全壘打很難說的 搞不好最後突然蹦好幾支出來
09/12 11:42
→
kirimaru73
只是今天是法官先蹦了兩隻
09/12 11:42
推
kotorichan
雷利55就有機會
09/12 11:44
→
saidon
為何55有機會 又不是啥指標性數字
09/12 11:47
推
Jaguarsu
左右開弓全壘打記錄是54隻
09/12 11:54
推
rayterzll
大谷今年拿第四座就是史上第二人了，MVP天花板大概都
09/12 11:56
→
rayterzll
在3座
09/12 11:56
推
cl3bp6
Raleigh上半季OPS還有1 現在剩0.925
09/12 12:10
推
kirimaru73
破左右開弓全壘打紀錄但是OPS輸快二成 這差距有點大
09/12 12:12
→
kirimaru73
除非破紀錄後再追加好幾轟
09/12 12:13
→
kirimaru73
法官1.1就是擺在那裡
09/12 12:13
推
greatthrow
早就說過MVP不可能給Raleigh了 他只贏全壘打而已 其他
09/12 12:47
→
greatthrow
數據還是法官完勝
09/12 12:47
推
white75724
沒辦法 法官進階數據還是完勝
09/12 14:07
推
w1g0824
雷利沒機會了 打擊數據差太多
09/12 15:40
推
kayuzzo15135
如果大谷留在美聯 去年贏不了法官
09/12 22:27
→
kayuzzo15135
今年應該也贏不了
09/12 22:28
→
kayuzzo15135
直接少兩座mvp
09/12 22:28
→
kayuzzo15135
留在天使
09/12 22:28
推
Sho17
要不要說法官轉來國聯也會直接少兩座mvp，說的好像大谷沒
09/12 23:25
→
Sho17
拿過美聯的
09/12 23:25
https://x.com/MLBONFOX/status/1966208200350511485
FOX兩位專家的預測
只有國聯的新人王有分歧
關於美聯MVP，這兩人的理由
It seems like all we’ve heard around baseball since the second half of the seas
on is the AL MVP debate. Let’s not make this complicated. It comes down to the
numbers. Judge has a 192 wRC+ and 7.9 fWAR; Raleigh has about a 158 wRC+ and 7.3
fWAR. Judge is slashing .321/.442/.660 with 44 homers; Raleigh is at roughly .2
40/.349/.574 with 53 homers. I’m not convinced that everything Raleigh does as
a switch-hitting catcher is enough to bridge the gap in Judge’s rate stats and
on-base/slugging advantage — roughly an 86-point difference in slugging — so t
his one still belongs to Judge. – Deesha Thosar
My heart says Cal Raleigh, but my head says Judge, who holds the advantage over
not only Raleigh but every qualified MLB hitter in every slash line category. Ju
dge shouldn’t be penalized just because this season isn’t quite as ridiculous
as last year, which was one of the greatest seasons from a right-handed hitter e
ver. His OPS is more than 150 points better than the next closest AL competitor,
he has reached base safely in 118 of his 133 games, and he had a terrific defen
sive season before the elbow injury. We shouldn’t lose sight of how ridiculous
he has been. – Rowan Kavner
大意就是覺得法官除了全壘打以外的打擊數據贏Raleigh太多了
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 223.139.21.7 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://webptt.cc/bbs/Baseball/M.1757645289.A.002.html
※ 編輯: polanco (223.139.21.7 臺灣), 09/12/2025 10:49:19